Monsanto clause is coming to town?

Many of you have probably never heard of HR 933, but it has been the cause of a lot of consternation among farmers, environmentalists and people with a vested interest in food and where it comes from.

HR 933: (Consolidated and Further Continuing Appropriations Act, 2013) is a bill that passed through the US house of representatives and was signed by President Obama in March, a pretty run-of-the-mill appropriations act, the kind of thing they pass all the time in order to keep the bills paid and the lights on. The bit that has people worries is tucked away in section 735. The text is as follows:

Sec. 735. In the event that a determination of non-regulated status made pursuant to section 411 of the Plant Protection Act is or has been invalidated or vacated, the Secretary of Agriculture shall, notwithstanding any other provision of law, upon request by a farmer, grower, farm operator, or producer, immediately grant temporary permit(s) or temporary deregulation in part, subject to necessary and appropriate conditions consistent with section 411(a) or 412(c) of the Plant Protection Act, which interim conditions shall authorize the movement, introduction, continued cultivation, commercialization and other specifically enumerated activities and requirements, including measures designed to mitigate or minimize potential adverse environmental effects, if any, relevant to the Secretary’s evaluation of the petition for non-regulated status, while ensuring that growers or other users are able to move, plant, cultivate, introduce into commerce and carry out other authorized activities in a timely manner: Provided, That all such conditions shall be applicable only for the interim period necessary for the Secretary to complete any required analyses or consultations related to the petition for non-regulated status: Provided further, That nothing in this section shall be construed as limiting the Secretary’s authority under section 411, 412 and 414 of the Plant Protection Act.

Pretty scary. Oh wait, you don’t understand what that means at all? Like most legislation, it’s written in antiquated legalese, not for the express purpose of confusing people, but actually to make sure the language is in no way ambiguous. Sure, most people can’t understand a word of it, but judges can, and it is mostly the courts who have to interpret these laws.

In essence, it gives permission to anyone to apply for a waiver on the usual requirements for growing trial crops. Big deal! Why shouldn’t they be able to grow trial crops? In this particular instance, it is relieving applicants from the usual checks and balances when introducing new, untested plant material that was previously covered by another act of congress, the Plant Protection Act. It also removes the ability of courts in the US to make rulings on the legality of certain plant materials and production operations.

Corn field

Corn (Zea mays) is one of the crops that has been extensively genetically modified, and is widely grown. Harvested corn is mostly used in food processing. Photo by Andrew Malone from flickr

This has been interpreted as allowing companies like Monsanto and others to grow previously untested GM crop material wherever they want without any investigation or burden of proof, as long as they have the permission of the Secretary of Agriculture. The fact it was drafted with the assistance of Monsanto is probably what is causing all the fuss.

It’s a pretty big deal, though there are some hopeful elements in there. The Secretary of Agriculture can refuse any permits whenever he wants. But presumably the companies who lobbied for this amendment to the bill have probably got the Secretary’s ear. It also includes a so-called “sunset clause” meaning it only applies for a limited time, but again, any bill can be extended by hiding away another amendment in another ordinary appropriations bill later on.

So, what does it mean for Australia? Not much. It applies to companies operating in the US, and has no real impact on Australian laws or legalities. But it has upset a lot of people, and understandably so. Everybody wants to know what is in their food, and the sneaky way this bill was passed indicates the companies behind the food technology industry are not altogether up-front about what they are doing, where it’s done or when.

A somewhat panicked response to the bill has seen marches around the world against Monsanto, but to be fair, they are only one of a group of companies who stand to benefit. Agro-chemical companies are at the top of the list of beneficiaries of this kind of research, but other companies stand to gain a lot from food technology research: the food processing industry.

Pretty much everything on supermarket shelves, almost all processed food, is not subject to any kind of labelling about GM ingredients. Many food processing companies contributed to a fund in the US to fight compulsory labelling of GM ingredients, due to what they saw as exorbitant costs to them, the producers. Some of them even own organic labels and brands.

In response to the so called “Monsanto Protection Act”, a list of food companies who are assumed to support Monsanto have been listed on various blogs and websites. I had a quick look through that list and identified some interesting facts and figures about the “companies” it lists. First of all, there are 69 “companies” on the list I linked to, mostly US labels for food we don’t get in Australia, but we have similar products from similar labels.

But those 69 names represent only 20 actual companies.

Of that 20 companies, only 6 companies in total own half the brands listed: ConAgra, General Mills, PepsiCo, Unilever, Nestlé and Campbells.

Monsanto doesn’t OWN these brands, or these companies, as some people have claimed. They are owned by much larger corporations whose individual profits dwarf those of Monsanto. Of the six companies listed above, the most profitable is Nestlé, who in 2011 posted a profit of over $10 billion US. Monsanto posted a profit about a tenth that size for the same year. Nestlé’s total sales for 2011 were in excess of $90 billion US, while Monsanto is worth about 1/5th of that in total assets.

Monsanto is the largest seed company in the world, selling almost a quarter of all seeds sold on the planet. Their next rival is DuPont, who only ten years ago were in the lead. The top ten seed companies sell more than two thirds of all seeds in the whole world. But stopping Monsanto won’t alter the skewed distribution. If they lose the lead, DuPont will regain their supremacy. If DuPont are forced out, Syngenta will take over, or Dow, and so on down the line. The people most happy about the Monsanto backlash are companies like Syngenta, DuPont, Bayer etc. who will profit from the demise of a rival, and release their own GM crops into the market place.

Soybeans are also a major GM crop, and also used in a wide variety of processed foods. Photo by Philip Dean on flickr

Soybeans are also a major GM crop, and also used in a wide variety of processed foods. Photo by Philip Dean on flickr

Most of the top agrochemical companies are seed producers, and also conduct GM research. But even in the US where the giants have taken a foothold, there are plenty of alternatives, just look at this list of smaller players in the US agriculture market.

The whole biotech/seed industry is dwarfed by the food processing industry for sales and profits. The top ten food processors in the US make far in excess of what these seed companies make. They are driven by profit as much as any other corporation, and they are the customers for GM agricultural commodities like corn and soybeans. They collectively fought hard against compulsory labelling of GM ingredients, as they suspect it will hurt their sales. They are probably right, and food processing giants employ psychologists to keep people virtually addicted to their food, rather than nutritionists to make sure it’s nourishing.

But if consumers are to have an impact in stopping production and sale of GM commodities, they need to target these corporate buyers. If nobody buys the GM product, no farmers will grow it, and the seed/agrochemical/biotech companies will turn elsewhere for their profits. Monsanto is a tiny piece of the global agrochemical puzzle. Protesting their existence is probably healthy, but they are not the lynchpin holding everything together.

People buying local, buying organic wherever possible and buying unprocessed or locally processed food is the best way to guarantee food security and reduce the profits of the huge food conglomerates, and discourage supporting companies like Monsanto from producing un-necessary genetically modified crops which people just don’t want to eat.

The key to food security is diversity. We don't want to put all of our seeds in one basket, but we also need a variety of seeds form a range of seed companies, farmers, growers and gardeners to ensure everyone has enough choice and enough to eat.

The key to food security is diversity. We don’t want to put all of our seeds in one basket, but we also need a variety of seeds from a range of seed companies, farmers, growers and gardeners to ensure everyone has enough choice, and enough to eat.

Grow your own, buy your own and cook your own food is about as simple a message as you can have. Support local farmers, and local seed companies and nurseries, and local fresh food retailers, rather the The Fresh Food People™. But for those who don’t have the spare time, money or energy to do that, the rest of us can still let food manufacturers know that it’s not okay to feed people the cheapest available food and not tell them what goes into it, and that way remove the potential problems that many perceive from GM and other agricultural technology.

They built this garden for us!

The Royal Botanic Gardens in Melbourne was established in the 19th century in part as a proving ground for plants from other parts of the world to evaluate how well they would respond to local conditions in Victoria. Since opening in 1846, the predominantly English garden tradition that shaped the early planting in the garden tried to recreate the gardenesque, pastoral aesthetic of Europe and Britain to help ease the transition of the newly arrived settlers by creating a familiar environment.

Of course, there was already a diverse and rich flora present in Australia, and the National Herbarium established by early Gardens director Ferdinand von Mueller attempted to document and record the rapidly vanishing flora which was often actively destroyed by the colonisation and settlement of the landscape. The appreciation of Australian native plants by gardeners and designers grew during the 20th century, and supporters of the Royal Botanic Gardens felt the need to expand the function of the gardens by including a representation of Australian native plants in a formal garden setting.

John Arnott explains the purpose of Stage 1 as we head for Stage 2, with a spectacular Waratah in flower behind him

The original site of the gardens was too small for this bold project, and a site near Cranbourne, in Melbourne’s South Eastern sand-belt was chosen and secured as the site for the Australian Garden. Stage 1 opened in 2006, and was a dramatic departure from the lush greenery of the South Yarra base of the Botanic Gardens, instead focusing around a bold, “red sand” feature evoking the red centre of Australia. The new garden builds on the success of Stage 1, continuing the story of water as it flows from the inland to the sea.

Water is the overall theme of the Australian Garden, from the inland creeks, here represented by an artificial water course…

…to the Melaleuca Spits, representing a river estuary (and showing in the background the heavy machinery of a work-in-progress)…

…to the unfinished and unfilled final water feature representing larger bodies of water such as lakes and the sea itself.

I was lucky enough to get a sneak preview of the gardens, led by head Horticulturist of the RBG Cranbourne, John Arnott. The water theme features heavily in the design, from the flowing water through stage 1, through to more expansive bodies of water representing rivers, lakes and the ocean.

The unusual Underground Banksia (Banksia bipinnatifida) which barely pokes it’s leaves and flower above the ground

But it’s the plants people really come to see, and they will not be disappointed. From a Cultivar garden near the entrance to Stage 2, which is intended as a dynamic display of modern nursery bred varieties and hybrids of native plants for ornamental gardens, through to the Weird and Wonderful garden, which aims to showcase some real oddball plants from a diverse range of habitats throughout the country, there is sure to be something here to please every stripe of gardener.

This odd looking stick -like plant is a desert dwelling member of the Pea family

Weird and wonderful plants can be found in the new section of the garden

In order to manage plants from every corner of the country, from high, cold, wet mountains to scorching dry, flat deserts, the landscape itself has been shaped into a variety of potential habitats, and as John says, it is in part an experiment to see what works, and what doesn’t.

It’s not often a new Botanic garden opens, and it must have been an amazing experience designing and building a garden on such epic scale. Even in its early stages, it really is an amazing achievement. The best way to see it is to visit for yourself, the Garden opens to the public officially on the 20th and 21st of October, 2012.

They mustard done this before…

I was in the Royal Botanic Gardens Melbourne over the weekend and spotted this under-planting of Mustard (Brassica juncea) in their species rose garden.

Mustard growing in the rose garden, but why?

I am not exactly sure why they have planted the mustard here. I am not a huge believer in “companion planting” which is the idea that certain plants somehow influence each others’ growth by means other than direct competition for nutrients, water and sunlight. There are a few plants that can exude chemicals into the soil from their roots, or through their leaves that runs off when it rains, but they are few and far between.

But there are reasons to include mixed planting, such as to increase the number of plants in a limited space. In this case, nobody benefits directly from the delicious looking vegies growing here, as visitors are not allowed to remove plant material from the gardens. They have planted more than one type of mustard here, too, so the decision could have been purely ornamental, and they do look quite attractive, even though they have now gone to flower.

Red Mustard in with the species Roses at RBGM, possibly to attract predator insects.

But the most likely reason, especially as they have been left to flower, is to attract predatory insects that will feed on pests of the Roses and other ornamental plants . Other Brassicas left to flower will do the same thing, but other families do too, including the Apiaceae family, which includes Parsley (Petroselinum crispum), Carrots (Daucus carota) and Coriander (Coriandrum sativum); and the Daisy family (Asteraceae), which includes Lettuce (Lactuca sativa), Chicory (Chicorium intybus) and Sunflowers (Helianthus anuum).

Some interpretive signs around the beds to explain this to curious visitors would be helpful. Maybe next year.

I feel the need: The need for seed!

Okay, we’re well on the way to the middle of spring, and it’s time to plant pretty much everything you might want to grow in the garden. I love this time of year, spring blossoms on the trees herald the beginnings of delicious stone fruits, and Apple and Pear blossoms are not far behind.

This Pear tree is exploding with blossoms, though it’s purely ornamental. Such a waste of space!

But the vegie garden is where it’s all really exciting, have a look at my planting calendar to get an idea what you can plant where you are, but pretty much, anything goes! Knock yourself out. I try to use open pollinated varieties of vegies and herbs, for the simple reason that you can save the seeds from your best plants to grow again next year. Biodiversity is so important in making sure we have enough food in the future, and the best way to preserve that diversity is to grow and save your own seeds.

Open pollinated means that the plants freely cross with each other, there’s no clever methods to follow to make sure they produce good seed, just let nature take its course. But open pollination means they will cross with other varieties of the same plant if they are growing close by. If you have two or more lettuce varieties, for instance, they will cross with each other when they flower, and the resulting seed will grow into a combination of the parents.

If you want to keep a variety pure, make sure it’s the only one flowering. The easiest way is to remove flowers from other plants until your selected plant has finished and produced seed. In my front garden I have a whole heap of different things growing, and I have left some of each to go to seed, Red Osaka Mustard, Tuscan Kale, Chinese Broccoli, Rocket and Black Spanish Radish have all gone to flower, but none of them will cross even though they are closely related.

So many flowers! The pale yellow Rocket flowers in the foreground don’t cross with the pink Radish flowers in the background, but both will produce more seed than I can use.

But Kale will cross with European Broccoli, and Turnips will cross with Chinese Cabbages and Broccoli. It can be a bit tricky. If you are a bit unsure, there are places to buy good, open pollinated seed so when you build up your confidence you can start keeping your own.

One of my favourite seed suppliers has only recently put up a website at Phoenix Seeds where you can view the catalogue and download order forms. Michael still likes to do business by mail, but his seeds are of top quality, all sourced as locally as possible for things he has no room to grow himself. Have a look through, he has vegies, herbs and other fruiting and useful seeds for sale. Give some of the unusual things a go, it’s always fun to grow something you’ve never even seen before.

Gloves will tear us apart

I try to propagate my own plants as much as I can. It’s usually cheaper than buying plants and it’s endlessly fascinating to watch the plants develop from seed or cuttings, or watch a grafted bud shoot away in the spring.

But for whatever reason, it’s not always possible, and we do sometimes have to buy plants, even if only to give ourselves some paterial to propagate from. To be accurate, buying seeds is buying plants anyway, just in their most compact and easily stored form!

French Sorrel in a pot: but there’s more than one plant in here.

I bought some herbs from a stall at a garden show some time ago, but I looked for pots that had multiple plants in them, so I got better value. You can see from the photos,the pot of French Sorrel (Rumex acetosa) I bought has more than a single plant in it,  leaves are emerging from more than one point.

French Sorrel divided showing numerous individual plants

I tipped out the pot and split the contents in half just by pulling them apart. I did break a few leaves, but that doesn’t really matter, they can be fed to the worms or thrown in a salad, depending on your preference. The important part is the individual stems, and as long as the roots are intact, the leaves will grow back.

Sorrel plants divided up

It’s a good idea when transplanting nursery grown or potted plants to remove all the potting mix from the roots, it forces the plant to grow roots into the surrounding soil and seek out nutrients and water, rather than staying in the comfortable surrounds of the potting mix with it’s ready supply of food, air and water. In this case I had to remove the potting mix to separate out the individual little plants.

Newly potted sorrel x17

There were more than 20 individual plants in the original pot I bought, but some were tiny, so I put them in the same container, and ended up with 17 pots of Sorrel from my initial purchase.

Sorrel is a perennial herb, which means it will naturally divide and continue to grow year after year. If clumps get too big, I can dig them up and divide them, and after a couple of weeks, I can plant these out in a row, or just share them around. It is quite happy in a container, too, just divide again when it gets too big. Sorrel is used all over the world as a fresh or cooked green, and has a delicious, slightly sour flavour. It is much used in French provincial cooking. Why not give it a try!

While you’re out there, see what joy division can give you. Look for plants with multiple stems emerging from the pot, especially herbaceous perennials like Sorrel, Globe Artichoke, Mint, Lovage and so many more. You are unlikely to harm the plant, just make sure each new section has roots and shoots or buds, and they will come good. Have fun!

I beg your pardon, I never promised you a rose garden

The following post is adapted from a workshop given at the Green Renters Expo in association with the City of Yarra, May 17th, 2011

I was challenged by my friends at Green Renters to put together a short talk about food gardening for people with limited access to an established garden. Trying to squeeze in as much as possible into such a short presentation (I really only had about half an hour) was pretty difficult, so I had to pare down the volumes of information about growing plants to the bare bones. This is what i came up with.

Gardening without a garden

Getting by with what you’ve got

Not everyone has a garden, and in the past, only the extremely wealthy could afford lavish gardens. Landed gentry had teams of gardeners on their estates tending to exotic plants collected from all around the world. As the middle class grew, smaller versions of these elaborate status symbols replaced the purely utilitarian vegie plots and orchards in suburban private gardens, and even in government owned properties. Status is fine, if you actually can afford it as the old fashioned lords could: they had their own productive land as well as the extensive show gardens. The average person does not have that luxury. In some cases, a patch of soil is not even available for any kind of garden.

The front yard of a nearby neighbour, every year it's full of vegies.

So, where can we put a garden? As one version of things goes, before all else: Let there be light! A successful, productive garden needs at least 6 hours a day of direct sunlight. There are plants that can grow in less light, but as our focus is on food for people, the less light there is, the fewer meals you will get from the space. Light is essential for plant growth, plants take energy fromsunlight and convert it into chemical energy which we can eat. The light should be preferably in the morning, as the afternoon sun is generally hotter, and will tend to stress the plants a bit more, but in the end, any light is good, as long as there’s enough of it.

If a garden bed already exists, choose it to start with. It’s easier to dig out old plants you dan’t want, and replace them than start a whole new garden. Sometimes, anyway. There are problems, especially with established woody plants, which can cause problems, but in most cases, an existing garden is a good place to begin. The next best place is a lawn area. Lawns require a lot of sun, so a healthy patch is a good indication that there is enough light and water to grow most other plants, including food!

But what if there’s no soil at all? Any open space can be used as a growing area. In the inner cities, large areas have been paved, conreted or covered with hard surfacing like asphalt to reduce maintenance. These places are perfect, if they get enough sun, we just have to consider options for growing in containers, which I will come back to. In actual fact, the ground may not be the only place to put containers, and anywhere there is close-to-level space, such as balconies, roof tops, or even stairways can be considered, taking safety and access into account, of course.

Containers don't have to be "plant pots"

Another thing to consider is access to water. Is there a tap nearby the area you are going to use? It makes it so much easier to keep things going if you aren’t having to lug heavy watering cans up and down stairs or hoist them on to roofs to alleviate the thirst of your garden, and they are thirsty. In summer you may have to water every other day, in containers, maybe every day. There are automated ways of doing this, but a hose and trigger spray nozzle are the easiest.

There are other advantages of inner city gardens such as a potential lack of frost, due to being off the ground, or surrounding bricks and paving keeping things war at night. There are also often lower populations of weeds and pests, due to the absence of other gardens nearby for them to migrate from.

What can you grow? Anything you like, really, the number of plants that can be grown are limited by climate, but in any location, there are hundreds of species of plant that can be grown productively. the first thing to consider is what do you like to eat? There’s not much point growing things that you don’t like, it takes just as much work to grow them, but you don’t get anything out of it. Everything is seasonal, too. Some things will grow all year, but most plants have an optimum time of year in a particular area. This usually means they are in season when they are also cheapest in the shops, so find unusual or expensive things, or things that don’t transport well for starters. Soft fruits, fresh herbs, tomatoes and salad vegies are my first thoughts, but it’s really up to you.

You can grow whatever you want in your space

So how can we grow a garden without garden beds? The first option is raised beds. These can work on lawns, if you don’t want to dig them up, but they can work on concrete or other paved surfaces, they behave just like large containers. Basically, you build a wall around the area you want to use, and fill it with “soil”, but I will come back to this. Of course you can use plant pots, or any other kind of container, polystyrene fruit boxes are easily obtained, usually for nothing, from local grocers, or markets (if you can find one). But really, you can use anything as a container, with a few important provisions.

Firstly, it has to hold “soil”, and I keep using scare quotes, because bringing in actual soil from somewhere else is expensive, and basically unsustainable in most cases, but we can work around that. Cheap potting mix is a good option. Supermarkets and big variety stores have potting mix for less than $5/25 litres. The one thing to note is the Australian Standrad logo. There are two standards for potting mix, Regular, which does not have to contain any fertiliser, and Premium, which contains enough for a few months. The standard means you are sure the mix contains no toxic chemicals, retains water and nutrients, drains okay, allows air down to the plant roots: all the things you need from a potting mix. The container itself must also have holes at the bottom to allow water to drain away, or roots become waterlogged.

Logo for the Australian standard (regular grade) potting mix. Premium grade is the same in red.

You need to fill up the container almost to the top, but not quite, as there needs to be some space, a “reservoir” for water to collect so it can filter into the potting mix. Don’t squash it down too much, either, it will settle when it’s watered in., and too much pressure will squash out all the air spaces in the mix, and suffocate your plants.

But where do we get our plants? If you’re buying plants, seeds are the cheapest way to do it. You’ll get more plants than you know what to do with from most packets of seeds. It’s best to buy things that are “open pollinated” if you can find them, which means you will be able to save this year’s seeds again for next year. But there are plenty of other ways to get plants. Division is one way, there are a lot of plants, like Mint and Oregano, and Thyme, where you can just dig a little bit of the plant from an existing one, and plant it where you want it to grow. A bit more complicated it taking cuttings, where you cut a small stem from an established plant, strip most of the lower leaves off and stick it in some potting mix. Eventually, if the cuttings are kept moist, and out of direct sun in a warm spot, like the top of the fridge, new roots will grow from the base, and you can plant the cuttings out. Rosemary and Sage work well this way.

Not too little, not too much, this Apple seedling finds things just right. Maybe I'll call it Goldilocks.

Fertiliser = Plant Food. Plants produce their own energy, but they need certain elements to build the machinery to do it. These come from the nutrients found in fertilisers. The most important are Nitrogen, Phosphorous and Potassium, or “NPK” in their chemical symbols. These can be found in both synthetic chemical fertilisers, or in organic fertilisers. Chemical fertilisers are easy to apply in small amounts to deliver large doses of appropriate nutrients, while organic fertilisers, mostly animal manures, require much larger quantities to be applied for the same result. For this reason, along with the issue of odour, some people choose to use chemical fertilisers. It’s a personal decision, really, it makes little difference to the plants, though organic fertilisers increase soil organic matter and microbial activity, which is a good thing, while chemical fertilisers are much easier to overdose on and produce undesirable effects.

Pests and Diseases are often the cause of much discouragement. Grubs and slugs and bugs can eat away plants literally overnight, but there are simple solutions. Firstly, the best defence is healthy plants, healthy plants seem to be attacked less by pest and disease, so keep them growing strong. Growing many different plants together, mixed up rather than in neat rows, seems to confuse any critters looking for a free feed. Lastly, there are plenty of low toxicity sprays that will knock back the baddies. Just remember they will also knock out any beneficial bugs as well, like ladybugs and hoverflies.

Grow as many different plants as you can in the space you've got, it helps confuse the pests, keep out weeds, and produce more food!

Weeds take up empty space in the garden. If you have weeds, it means you could have more plants you like. Pulling weeds makes more weeds! By ripping them out, you are bringing more weed seeds to the surface, and allowing more sunlight to warm the soil, and more water to germinate more seeds. Mulch reduces weeding and watering, by shielding the soil from the sun, evaporation is reduced, so more water stays in the soil for plant roots. Organic mulches provide some nutrients as they break down, but very woody mulches can use up some nitrogen if you are not careful. Any mulch is better than nothing, even stones or plastic could help stop weeds and hang on to water.

Many plants produce more when harvested, like beans, peas, salad greens, even broccoli, so keep picking! Keep sowing seeds, too, on a regular basis, so plants can be replaced when they are slowing down. Most of all, keep trying, take notes so you can look back on what works and what doesn’t, and don’t get discouraged. No one is good at something the first time they try. Remember learning to cook?

The golden garden rules

  • Light
  • Water
  • Healthy roots = healthy shoots
  • Mulch
  • Plant what you like
  • Keep planting
  • Keep picking
  • Learn from mistakes
  • Have fun!

Growing the seeds of stuff

So much of what is written about growing food is based on commercial information. The methods of broadscale monocultures are scaled down to home gardens, based on the experience and research of commercial food production. But this may not be the best way to go about growing things in a local home garden.

Fruit trees are a good example of what I mean. In commercial orchards, trees are grown and maintained in a very uniform way. The aim is to get a large quantity of uniform fruit for market, ripening at the same time on multiple trees in plantations of dozens or hundreds of trees. The spraying, pruning, picking and processing of the fruit is streamlined to reduce costs to the grower. The trees all grow genetically identical fruit on selected rootstocks to reduce pest and disease problems. Such problems are concentrated by growing only one kind of plant in such mass plantings as orchards.

These problems for the most part do not apply to home growers. Further, the predictability of known varieties, those which are sold in bulk by supermarkets and grocers, are of benefit to mass production, allowing growers to systematically produce crops at set times of year. The existence of such monocultures are the main cause of chemical pesticide use in agriculture and horticulture. Large scale operations require mechanised simple solutions for economic reasons.

A bit less than a week's worth of seeds from my house, that's dozens of plants, right there.

When European settlers first arrived in Australia, they were forced to select and breed new varieties of plants and animals for the new conditions here. The climate, seasons and soils were so alien to their experience that varieties from “home” were not as predictable or productive as they were used to. Now faced with changes to climate, including temperature and weather patterns, we must begin to select new varieties that can cope with altered conditions.

Luckily for us, nature has a means of doing so quite easily: seeds. Every seed contains a variation on the genetics of it’s parent plant. Sexual reproduction in plants allows them to adapt to new environments and survive, and there is no reason home gardeners can’t take advantage of that natural adaptability. But the only way to do that is by letting those seeds grow. Existing plants can’t adapt to changed conditions in the same way their offsrping may be able to.

Many fruits we eat contain seeds, and there is no reason a home gardener can’t plant those seeds and grow new varieties of fruit which are unknown in the world. The vegetatively reproduced commercial varieties are well known to us for reasons of consumer preference, but mostly for shelf life, transportability, and ease of production by large scale growers. The price of fruit at market is influenced by season, but also by costs to the producers. Home gardeners, by having only one or two of a particular kind of fruit tree can avoid the broad scale pest and disease problems of the commercial growers, and by growing seedlings, could find new varieties with resistance to pests, diseases, or changed climatic conditions, such as lower water availability or reduced chilling periods.

Planting the seeds of the apples we eat, for example, will produce seedling apple trees. If we plant those seedlings in the ground, we find which are best suited to our actual soils and other conditions. The ones that thrive are evidently more suited to our specific location. Leaving them to mature and produce fruit will give us further information about their suitability for particular areas and seasons, and good record keeping will allow us to share that information with others. Finally, when the fruit appears, and admittedly this may be five or more years after planting seeds, we can pick it, and taste it, and decide whether it is an improvement on what we get in the supermarket.

In the vast majority of cases, if the fruit is not to our taste, or without some particular use, it can often be grafted with something more to our liking. The chances of it being radically different from the fruit we first took seeds from is very small, because of the way fruit is grown. The plants that pollinated the apple we bought are virtually identical, so the gene pool is quite small. But other features, such as disease tolerance, could make it a superior plant, even if the taste is exactly the same. But there is a chance it could taste better, be sweeter, have bigger fruit, ripen earlier or later, or any number of slight variations which may be improvements on the original. And no matter what, you get to name the new variety whatever you wish, as every seedling is a new variety, no matter how similar to it’s parents.

WARNING: May contain cases of nuts: I bought these for $10 from the local market, that's almost two hundred potential nut trees from a 1KG bag. To be precise, it's 129 Almonds, 23 Brazil nuts, 25 Hazelnuts, 15 Macadamias and 7 Walnuts. No prize for guessing what's the cheapest nut per kilo.

In the case of nuts, one of the major concerns for growers is uniformity of size, and that is one of the main reasons they grow selected varieties, so they know their harvest will be uniform. This carries over to processors, who often have machinery for shelling specific sizes. If the nuts aren’t the right siz, they won’t buy them. Most of the nuts in their shells on the retail market are “non uniform” for this reason. But if you’re going to sit around at Christmas with a nutcracker opening them by hand, what difference does it make to you?

There are restrictions as far as what will grow where. But when growing seedlings for basically no outlay, you can try whatever you want. Avocadoes and Macadamias grow quite happily in Melbourne, for example, but as far as I know, Brazil Nuts do not. There is no reason not to plant a few and see what happens, though. Sure, the frost might get to them, but then again, you may grow the first frost tolerant Brazil nut in the world. If it can be done, it won’t happen by sticking with the known varieties, that’s for sure, it needs seed-generated biodiversity for changes to happen, and those changes might be needed quite soon.

I’ve mentioned before that some of the most popular varieties, for example Granny Smith Apples, began as chance seedlings. If everyone with a garden grew a few seedling fruit trees, imagine how much genetic diversity would be cultivated in a single suburb, not to mention how much food could be produced. Sure, the tree you grow may not be your favourite orange, or pear, the walnuts your tree produces may be smaller than those in the shops, the mandarins might be seedier than you’d prefer, but surely it’s better than no food at all? And if it costs nothing, there’s nothing to lose.

So, keep your seeds in a paper bag, maybe even in the fridge, then plant them out in spring. Except Avocadoes which can go in any time, really, though they may not grow until the weather is warm. Give it a go. Even if you don’t have space for a Walnut tree, you could always sneak it in to the nature strip somewhere.

The way things are goin’, they’re gonna crucifer me

Someone asked me the other day if they could eat Broccolini leaves. They wanted to use them in a recipe, some kind of quiche-like tart which called for Kale to add some greenery. The answer was “Of course you can, they are the same thing”. Because ultimately, they are the same plant species. In south-western Europe, sometime in prehistory, people began to eat a plant now known as Brassica oleracea, a tough plant, tolerant of limestone soils and salt laden winds, which stores water in its fleshy leaves to cope with its harsh native habitat. The plant is a good source of vitamins, including vitamin C, and minerals, containing the highest levels of calcium among vegetable sources. The plant used to belong to the family Cruciferae, so called because of the cross-shaped flowers they all possess. The family name was changed relatively recently to Brassicaceae, and includes many edible plants, including Mustard, Turnips & Swedes, and Radishes, to name a few obvious examples.

A browse through the bounty of the Brassicaceae family, Choi Sum, Cauliflower and Daikon radish

But most surprising to me is the variety of “different” vegetables that are all contained within the species B. oleracea. The list includes many favourite, and commonly grown vegies, at least one of which most people would eat weekly, if not daily. Things like Kale, Collard Greens, Borecole, Broccoli, Cauliflower, Cabbage, the misinterpreted Kohl Rabi, and the unfairly maligned Brussels Sprouts all spring from the same source. You can track the origin through their names, which mostly contain a variant of “Cole”. This also gives us the name of the ubiquitous coleslaw, derived from the name for cabbage salad: No cole, no coleslaw. Let me elaborate further by discussing each in detail.

Kale, Collards and Borecole

These plants are probably the most closely related to the original wild species, and are grown for their leaves. They are collectively grouped as B. oleracea var. Acephala, the varietal name indicating they have no head, as a cabbage does. Borecole comes from a  Dutch name, Boerenkool, meaning peasant’s cabbage, but genetically these plants are very closely related. This biennial plant (meaning it flowers in its second year of growth) is resistant to frost, and can grow to nearly two metres if left alone.

The currently fashionable Cavallo Nero is really just a variety of Kale. Once regarded as peasant food, now a gourmet vegetable. Some peasant labour is clearly needed in this community garden plot at the Collingwood Children's Farm.

The appearance of some varieties is quite ornamental, and they can easily be hidden amongst flowers in a more ornamental garden, though I am not sure who can justify the time, water, space and effort to grow plants purely for appearance. Some Kales are grown purely for ornamental purposes, and can be found more often in the florist than the greengrocer’s. They have frilly, feathered, brightly coloured purple and white leaves – almost forming Cabbage-like heads in some cases. These are still edible, though the flavour is not great. I suppose like most things, it depends how hungry you are.

One of the most common colour variations in Kale varieties, as well as the other Brassicas, is a purple hue, like this Purple Kale. It usually changes to a blueish colour when cooked.

Kale can be grown pretty much any time of year, and harvested throughout its life cycle. The plants will love a high nitrogen supply, and will probably do better if some liquid fertiliser is applied as they grow. Just remember that the leaves give the plant energy, so if you take them all, recovery will probably be slow, and you may shock the plant into flowering. But you can always cut back the flower heads and keep on gutsing the leaves.

Cabbage

The name Cabbage is possibly a corruption of the Latin for head, caput, referring to the growth of a large ball of leaves in the centre of the plant. This head has been selected over centuries, and is an important food in many parts of the world. In fact, despite being relatively low in energy content, they are high in vitamins and minerals, and remain one of the most grown vegetables. Highest production annually is in China, followed somewhat unsurprisingly by India then the Russian Federation. I have to admit the true Cabbages are among my least favourite of the species. I rarely buy them except with specific recipes in mind, while others I grow all the time or buy routinely, when in season.

The humble Cabbage, growing at the Collingwood Childrens' Farm community garden

There are a huge number of cultivated varieties of cabbage, in numerous shapes, colours and textures, but these are not to be confused with the Asian Cabbages which have often been bred from the related Turnip, or from Mustard. European Cabbages are commonly pickled, such as in sauerkraut, as well as being eaten fresh or cooked in a huge variety of dishes. There are varieties that may be grown all year round, and cut plants will often resprout smaller heads after the main head is removed. The most commonly eaten part is the tightly bound “head” of young, immature leaves, which make the plants compact compared with their close relatives. If left until their second year, a flower stalk will burst through the head, which by this time will be less than palatable, but still technically edible.

Keep sowing a few at a time to avoid a harvest season glut.

Cabbages grow in most places, they will tolerate frost, and grow best at cooler times of year. They like fertile soil in full sun, with plenty of compost and organic fertiliser. They may bolt in hot weather, so harvest as soon as they ready, and plant successively for a continuous supply. This applies to all the Brassicas mentioned here. A few every week is better than a dozen at once come harvest time.  They are ready to harvest in 7-14 weeks depending on the variety.

Broccoli

Broccoli, or more specifically B. oleracea var. Italica has been selected, initially in Italy about two thousand years ago, for the flowering stems of the plant. There are numerous varieties, as one would expect, the most common producing large branching flower heads that look like little trees. This similarity may make it easier to get little people to consume this vegetable, and is worth a try if you have trouble in that department. Sing the Lumberjack song while you eat, if it helps. The generally bluish plants are best grown through the winter as hot weather can make them bolt to seed. They will flower eventually if the heads are not harvested, though again most of the plant is edible anyway, including the flowering stems. They will handle frost, and to get the largest possible heads should be planted 40 – 60cm apart, though closer plants will produce smaller heads.

Broccoli can produce very large heads, like this 40cm monster at the Collingwood Children's Farm gardens. Closer planting means smaller heads, which is more useful for smaller households.

It is thought by some to be a cross between heading Cabbage and the Cauliflower, originally, and has been known in Southern Europe since before the Medicis, who took the plant from Italy to France in the 1500s. By the early 1600s it had made its way to England, and it was planted at Norfolk island as early as 1788, making it among the first vegetables from Europe to be grown in the colonies. There are Green and Purple Sprouting Calabrese varieties, which give a continuous supply of shoots after the main harvest, and there are Perennial varieties which can be kept going for months at a time by continuous harvesting of the side shoots.

Broccoflower like this example at the Queen Victoria Market, is an actual cross between Broccoli and Cauliflower, and has the same growing preferences as Broccoli.

Broccoli is probably my personal favourite of this species, and in the garden, they are not only easy to grow, but many varities produce side shoots after the main “head” is removed, providing ongoing broccoli feasts. Most people are aware the stalks are edible, though the larger they are, the tougher they get. I still use the thick main stalks in the kitchen, peeling away the fibrous outer layers of skin and chopping up the softer insides to use in soups and stews. I have even chopped and then frozen the stalks if I didn’t need them straight away. Delicious.

There's some debate about whether the fractal-patterned Romanesco Broccoli is a Cauliflower or a Broccoli, but it can be treated as either.

The vegetable known as Broccolini, Brocoletti or Baby Broccoli is generally the side shoots, developed after the main head is harvested, though some varieties of Broccoli have been selected specifically to provide these smaller shoots.

Cauliflower

The curds of the Cauliflower are the most eaten part of the plant, they grow much the same as for Cabbages, but tolerate less heat and frost. Heat particularly will break up the compact heads and induce flowering quickly, though of course they are still edible beyond this point. Again, a continuous planting will result in a  continuous supply at harvest. Despite being known in ancient times in the Middle East and North Africa, the Cauliflower didn’t make it to England until the 18th century. Though they were well known in Australia by the early 19th century. There are white, green and purple headed varieties available, so you can be creative with their planting, and they mature in 12-20 weeks, again doing best through the cooler part of the year.

Call me old fashioned, but sometimes I crave Cauliflower in Cheese sauce. Pakora are pretty good, too.

Kohl Rabi

Something of an oddity, the Kohl Rabi is sometimes known as the Turnip Rooted Cabbage, due to the swollen base of the plant. It is in fact the stem that swell, rather than the root, but the Kohl Rabi is treated as a root vegetable nonetheless. It is grown in cooler climates from Spring to Autumn, opposite seasons in warm places. But as it’s mid-winter here, it’s the only type of B. oleracea I could find neither growing nor in the market. The varietal name Gongylodes refers specifically to the “Cabbage Turnip”, if the common name is translated from the original German. Plants must be grown quickly to avoid the swollen stems becoming tough. Several purple tinged varieties are available, but only the skin is pigmented, the edible flesh inside the stem is white or yellowish. The vegetable has a mild cabbage flavour, not unlike Broccoli stems or cauliflower, and is commonly used in stews and soups similar to Turnips, though in North Africa and other places the leaves are commonly eaten also. These cultivars have only been known for a bit over five hundred years.

Brussels Sprouts

Possibly the most hated of Cabbages, the Brussels Sprout has a bad reputation especially among children. I say GOOD, that leaves more for me. The Brussels Sprout, or Choux de Bruxelles, was developed some time before the 13th century when the first records appear in Belgian market records. It didn’t make much headway in the English speaking world until a few centuries later later, and probably arrived in Australia late in the 19th century, but remaining obscure until after the Second World War. The plants do best in a cold climate, so are not really suited north of Sydney or along the coast, but are quite happy in Victoria and Tasmania. They were often included in traditional English Christmas dinners, mainly because they, along with Leeks (Allium ampeloprasum) are one of the few things left standing in the garden at that time of year. Many gardeners will insist that a good frost (or a snowfall) will improve their flavour, but in the cities of Australia, that occurrence is increasingly unlikely. They are planted in late Summer or Autumn, and harvested 12 – 20 weeks later, depending on the variety and the season. The plants need a fair amount of space, and grow quite tall, the sprouts themselves forming along the leaf axils, and may need staking especially in shallow or loose soils. Some popular old varieties to look for are Long Island Improved, an old standard non-hybrid variety, and Ruby Red, which as the name suggests will add some colour to the already interesting looking plants.

Not all that popular among inner city growers, probably because they take up a lot of space for a relatively long time. People still want to eat them, though, Brussels Sprouts for sale at the Richmond market with Broccolini

A particular pest: The Cabbage White Butterfly

I’ve already written about the major pest of this species, the prolific and devastating Cabbage White Butterfly (Pieris rapae). They can wipe out a crop of Brassicas in a couple of days, especially when young, and seem to be more of an issue than the other big garden pest snails and slugs.

I started a choke, that started the whole world laughing

Everyone knows what Artichokes look like, right? Of course. They come in a jar marinated in oil and vinegar and garlic. If you look at my planting calendar you will see that in many parts of the country it’s the time of year for planting Artichokes, it’s also time to plant a couple of other things, which are known as Artichokes, but are quite different in almost every way.

Globe Artichokes (Cynara cardunculus var. scolymus) are what we call the Artichokes known to us from Mediterranean cuisine. They are the flower buds of a perennial thistle, originally native to Southern Europe. They are easy to grow in most parts of Australia, though they may be susceptible to cold in some areas without protection during winter. The plants are attractive, and are sometimes incorporated in ornamental gardens just for their impressive spiny foliage and silvery appearance. But to be honest, they take up a huge amount of space, and produce a very meagre return, once a year. Basically, if you are have limited space, I’d give them a miss.

The single sad leaf of my Globe Artichoke. When it gets bigger, I will be forced to make a decision about whether it's worth the space.

I would not say the same of the terribly named Jerusalem Artichoke (Helianthus tuberosus). I say terribly named, because neither part of that name is accurate. It is not from Jerusalem, and is almost exactly unlike an Artichoke. This relative of the Sunflower is originally from North America, where it can still be found growing wild throughout the warmer states like California. Though botanically it is in the same family as the true Artichoke, the daisy family (Asteraceae) the relationship is distant. The edible part of this plant is the tubers, which form in tight clumps around the base of the plants, and can be dug up in winter. While they are difficult to peel because of their knobbly shape, they are relatively flavourless, the starch-like texture being reminiscent of potatoes, and they can be used in much the same way.

In fact it is not starch, but inulin that is stored in the tubers, which is only partially digestible by the human digestive system, and is suitable for diabetic diets. It may also cause bloating and gas in some people, due to this lack of digestion. There is some interest in the crop being used to create ethanol fuel, too. Apparently, early Italian settlers in the US called the plant “Girasole”, which probably became corrupted to Jerusalem over time, and the flavour has been compared to Artichoke by more than one taster. Many people are trying to popularise the names “Sunchoke” and “Sunroot” as alternative names, to avoid confusion. The plants grow easily, and can be left in place without much trouble, though tuber size and quality does decline with time. Try planting them with a perennial climber, like a Runner Bean (Phaseolus coccineus) to maximise the vertical productivity, the tall Sunflower-like plants provide sturdy support, and provide much needed shade in summer.

Assorted shapes and sizes of Jerusalem Artichoke tubers, ready for planting. The green patches on these are not toxic like those on Potatoes.

The third plant I wanted to mention is the Chinese Artichoke (Stachys affinis). Presumably this picked up the Artichoke moniker because of the tubers it produces being compared to the Jerusalem Artichoke, though it’s a tenuous comparison. This plant is a member of the mint family (Lamiaceae), and closely related to the common ornamental Lamb’s Ears (Stachys byzantina). The crunchy tubers are commonly used in China and Japan, less so elsewhere. The leaves may be eaten, but usually only in emergencies. Again this plant can be pretty much left alone, and it’s unlikely every tuber will be found at harvest, so it will most likely spring up on its own year after year. I grew mine in a pot, so I could easily find them when the plant top died back.

A heap of tubers from one Chinese Artichoke plant. They are being stored in moist coco-peat to prevent them drying out.

Anyway, it’s the right time to plant any of these three plants, but as I said, unless you have heaps of space, I would avoid the Globe Artichokes, and possibly stick to the other two. But I do like perennials that don’t need replanting every year, it’s so much easier that way.

It’s not easy being green

I was hanging out my washing the other day, and when I finished, I found a little visitor had jumped into the empty washing basket. I’d have probably missed him otherwise, but as he was essentially trapped, I whipped out my phone and took a picture of the little critter. You can see his picture below, and by my guess, he had blown or fallen down from the gigantic LabLab Bean I have growing over the laundry.

Everyone meet the imaginatively named Green Vegetable Bug. GVB, this is everyone.

This little guy is a Green Vegetable Bug (Nazara viridula) and is a common pest of pulses. This includes beans, peas, lentils, soybeans and pretty much everything vaguely related to beans except for Chickpeas (Cicer arietinum). These guys are actual bugs, which if you were an entomologist would mean something useful in describing their life cycle. Let’s just say for now, all bugs are insects, but not all insects are bugs. GVBs hatch from yellowish egg clusters, and grow in stages, called instars, until they are full sized adults. The young look more or less the same as the grown-ups, except for the colouration.

The thing that really sucks about these guys is they really do suck. They use their piercing mouthparts to poke into almost developed beans in their pods, and suck all the goodness out. That means less for us to eat, or at the very least, sad looking, mis-shapen beans or peas. In really bad infestations, there may be up to 20 bugs per square metre, which means a lot of damaged beans. They can also attack flowers and early pods, too, reducing yields even further, and may suck sap from other plants including corn, sunflowers and tomatoes. They are also becoming a problem in commercial cotton crops, and with the the amount of pesticides already used on that crop, they may be developing resistance to chemical sprays.  They don’t like being disturbed, and will actually spray a stinky substance that can stain your skin or clothing. Little skunks.

They can be controlled with chemical sprays, though they can be pretty toxic. They are relatively easy to catch and kill by hand, if you can see them first, but wear gloves to avoid being stinkified. There are two parasitic wasps that will help keep their numbers down, one which destroys their eggs (Trissolcus basalis) and another which attacks the adult bugs (Trichopoda giacomellii). You can search for suppliers on the internet, and most companies will mail the appropriate predator along with instructions. The thing to remember is to avoid other pesticides that could harm the good guys once they are released.

I am sure you will see them around once you start looking, but possibly not so much in the colder months. I think mine was looking for somewhere warm to hide.

« Older entries

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 289 other followers

%d bloggers like this: